How to lower your car insurance premiums: 12 Effective strategies

Efficient allocation of financial resources is a fundamental principle across various aspects of life, encompassing essential expenses such as fuel, housing, and telecommunication services. In parallel, prudent management of one’s automotive insurance expenditure is equally imperative. Analogous to seeking favorable terms for other consumables, proactive measures can be undertaken to mitigate the costs associated with car insurance.

Considering the prevailing average annual expenditure of $1,556 for car insurance among good drivers in the United States, even marginal reductions ranging from 5% to 10% can yield tangible financial benefits. Moreover, instances exist where substantial reductions of 30% or more are attainable. To facilitate this endeavor, the following compendium delineates ten meticulously curated strategies aimed at optimizing your car insurance premiums.


1. Shop Around

The savvy consumer instinct to seek out cost-effective options extends beyond discretionary purchases like electronics and apparel to encompass essential financial considerations such as car insurance.

Whether embarking on the initiation of coverage, revisiting policy renewal, or contemplating a transition to a new insurer, overlooking the potential savings afforded by juxtaposing rates from multiple auto insurance providers would be remiss.


Significant discrepancies in car insurance premiums for identical coverage levels persist among insurance carriers, underscoring the importance of diligent market exploration. Failure to engage in comparative analysis foregoes the opportunity to ascertain potential cost reductions. Guidance from industry authorities such as the Insurance Information Institute advocates for soliciting quotes from a minimum of three insurers to facilitate a comprehensive evaluation of both costs and coverage terms.

Vigilance in ensuring parity across policy parameters is paramount to enable an equitable apples-to-apples assessment of pricing structures.

2. Review Your Deductibles

Rebekah Nelson, serving as a representative for USAA, advises policyholders to undertake a thorough review of the deductible parameters embedded within their existing coverage, with the aim of potentially adjusting them upwards.

According to Nelson, revisiting this aspect of your policy, particularly if it has been overlooked for some time, may reveal that a higher deductible aligns more suitably with your circumstances and can consequently result in a reduction of your premium.

Defined as the amount subtracted from an insurance claim in the event of filing for comprehensive or collision coverage, a car insurance deductible is determined at the inception of a policy and can be modified subsequently. Opting for a higher deductible translates to a commensurate reduction in premium expenses. This is predicated on the rationale that policyholders, by accepting a greater portion of the financial responsibility in the event of a claim, are incentivized to exercise restraint in filing for minor damages, given that the repair costs are unlikely to surpass the deductible threshold by a significant margin.


As per insights from the Insurance Information Institute, elevating your deductible from $200 to $500 has the potential to yield a notable reduction of 15% to 30% in the costs associated with collision and comprehensive coverage. Further escalating the deductible to $1,000 could precipitate even more substantial savings, estimated at 40% or higher.

The Institute further underscores the importance of prudent financial planning, advising policyholders to set aside adequate reserves in anticipation of potential claim scenarios. For instance, in the event of a collision entailing a $5,000 payout and a $1,000 deductible, the insurance provider would cover $4,000, leaving the policyholder accountable for the remaining $1,000 in out-of-pocket expenses for vehicle repair.

3. Bundle Insurance Policies

Television advertisements frequently highlight the advantages of consolidating auto and home insurance policies. A prevalent practice among insurance providers, bundling policies entitles policyholders to discounts, a benefit that extends beyond auto and home coverage to include other types such as motorcycle and boat insurance.

Typically referred to as a bundling discount or multi-policy discount, this incentive can yield savings ranging from 5% to 25%.


Beyond the potential for discounted premiums, Rebekah Nelson underscores the added convenience of consolidating multiple policies under a single insurer. This streamlined approach to insurance management offers policyholders greater simplicity and coherence in their coverage arrangements.

4. Explore Car Insurance Discounts

Auto insurance providers offer an array of discounts beyond bundling incentives. Among the most prevalent are:

1. Multi-car discount: Insuring multiple vehicles under the same policy may result in savings ranging from 8% to 25%.

2. Vehicle safety discount: Vehicles equipped with advanced safety features, such as anti-lock brakes and airbags, may qualify for a discount.

3. New car discount: Ownership of a vehicle less than three years old can merit a discount of 10% to 15%.


4. Good driver discount: Demonstrated safe driving habits, evidenced by a clean record devoid of accidents or traffic violations over a specified duration, may warrant discounts ranging from 10% to 40%.

5. Good student discount: High academic achievement can translate into financial benefits, with discounts ranging from 8% to 25% extended to full-time high school or college students aged 16 to 25 maintaining a minimum B average.

5. Let Your Insurer Track Your Driving

Several car insurance providers offer the opportunity to potentially reduce premiums through enrollment in usage-based insurance programs. These initiatives utilize either a dedicated mobile application or a device installed within the vehicle to monitor driving behavior. Parameters tracked typically include mileage, speed, and frequency of abrupt braking incidents.

Demonstrating commendable driving habits as evidenced by the collected data can render policyholders eligible for discounted rates. For instance, participants in USAA’s SafePilot program stand to benefit from discounts of up to 30%. Other notable examples of usage-based car insurance programs encompass Snapshot by Progressive, Drive Safe & Save by State Farm, and Drivewise by Allstate.

It is important to note, however, that as highlighted in TransUnion’s “Insurance Trends and Outlook” report for 2022, there are instances where enrollment in usage-based insurance may lead to increased premiums. Optimal suitability for such programs is often found among drivers with low mileage, minimal nighttime driving, and exemplary adherence to safe driving practices.

6. Take a Defensive Driving Course

The completion of an accredited defensive driving course, sanctioned by your insurance provider, presents an opportunity for reduced car insurance premiums. As an illustration, drivers residing in Texas who successfully complete an online defensive driving course endorsed by Geico may qualify for a discount of up to 10% for a duration of three years. Similarly, in New York, completion of an approved driving safety course can lead to a 10% reduction in insurance rates over a three-year period.

7. Park in the Garage

Certain insurance companies offer reduced car insurance premiums contingent upon parking your vehicle in a home garage rather than leaving it in a driveway or on the street. Statistical evidence suggests that vehicles parked in garages are less susceptible to theft or damage resulting from accidents.

8. Drive a Safe Car with Low Repair Costs

When navigating through the process of purchasing a vehicle, whether in-person at dealerships or through online platforms, it is essential to factor in the specific type of car you intend to acquire. It is pertinent to note that certain vehicles incur lower insurance costs compared to others.

In addition to individual factors such as age and driving history, insurance companies take into consideration the make and model of the vehicle when determining coverage rates. Various metrics are assessed, including the vehicle’s susceptibility to theft, the average repair costs associated with the model, its safety ratings, and the frequency of insurance claims filed for similar models.

Resources such as the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety provide comprehensive safety ratings for numerous vehicle models, alongside data depicting the percentage deviation from the average number of claims for specific vehicle classes. Similarly, the National Insurance Crime Bureau annually releases a list of the most frequently stolen vehicles, aiding prospective buyers in making informed decisions regarding vehicle selection.

9. Boost Your Credit if Possible

The majority of states permit insurance providers to utilize credit-based insurance scores as a factor in calculating car insurance premiums. This score serves as a predictive measure of the likelihood of a policyholder filing a car insurance claim. Generally, lower credit-based scores correlate with higher probabilities of costly claims being made. Improving your traditional credit score may consequently result in an enhancement of your credit-based insurance score, potentially leading to more favorable car insurance rates.

An analysis conducted by Forbes Advisor revealed that drivers with poor credit profiles typically face average premiums that are 76% higher compared to those with favorable credit standings.

10. Pay Your Premium in Full if Possible

Rather than opting for monthly premium payments, deliberate on the option of remitting your entire premium in a single installment. Numerous car insurance providers extend a modest discount as an incentive for policyholders who choose this payment method. Notable insurance companies such as Progressive, Allstate, American Family, and Farmers are among those that offer this discount to their clientele.

11. Research insurance costs before deciding on what car you want

The choice of vehicle significantly influences your insurance premium, with certain models commanding higher insurance costs than others. For instance, the insurance rate for a high-performance sports car differs markedly from that of a safety-focused minivan.

When contemplating the purchase of a new vehicle, it is imperative to assess the potential insurance expenses associated with the chosen model. It is worth noting that affordability alone does not necessarily equate to lower insurance premiums.

In selecting your vehicle, it is prudent to recognize that repair costs play a pivotal role in determining insurance rates. Therefore, features such as upgraded trim levels, advanced audio systems, and additional technological enhancements may impact insurance costs.


Notably, vehicles renowned for their comparatively lower insurance rates include:

– Subaru Outback
– Jeep Wrangler
– Honda CR-V
– Subaru Forester
– Ford Escape
– Ford F-150

12. Look into ways you can save with teen drivers

The inclusion of a teenage driver on your insurance policy typically results in increased premiums. However, there are strategies available to mitigate the extent of this rise.

Many insurance providers, such as Liberty Mutual, extend discounts tailored for teenage drivers who demonstrate academic excellence, reside away from home for educational purposes, or opt for a higher deductible.


Are car insurance premiums going up in 2024?

According to the Consumer Price Index compiled by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, car insurance premiums experienced an average increase of 20.6% between February 2023 and February 2024.


Why is car insurance so expensive right now?

One contributing factor to the rise in car insurance premiums, as highlighted by the Insurance Information Institute, is the escalation in severe accidents. Additionally, challenges within the supply chain and the integration of increasingly complex technology in vehicles have resulted in elevated new car prices. Consequently, this upward trend in new car prices has exerted pressure on insurance premiums, as noted by the Congressional Research Service.

How much is car insurance?

As of March 2024, Bankrate data indicates that the average annual premium for full coverage car insurance stands at $2,545, equating to approximately $212 per month. For minimum coverage, the average annual premium is reported at $741, translating to approximately $62 per month.

Bottom line

While car insurance premiums are on the rise, implementing strategic measures such as bundling insurance policies, leveraging available discounts, and adopting prudent decision-making can help mitigate the impact of escalating prices.


1. Geico

Automobile insurance rates: Competitive
Collision repair services: Acceptable
Level of customer complaints: Low

Explore and compare rates from our network of trusted partners through EverQuote’s secure platform.


Automobile insurance rates: Outstanding
Collision repair services: Satisfactory
Level of customer complaints: Moderate

Discover and evaluate rates from our network of reputable partners through EverQuote’s secure online platform.

3. State Farm

Automobile insurance rates: Highly favorable
Collision repair services: Adequate
Level of customer complaints: Minimal

Evaluate and compare rates from our reputable partners through EverQuote’s secure online platform.

Reviewed by:

  • USAgov (formerly Federal Citizen Information Center): Visit for comprehensive information and resources.
  • National Consumers League: For consumer advocacy and education, access
  • USDA NIFA | National Institute of Food and Agriculture (formerly Cooperative State Research, Education, and Extension Service, USDA): Explore agricultural research and education initiatives at


Amy Danise

Amy Danise is the managing editor for and Forbes Advisor's insurance section, covering auto, home, renters, life, pet, travel, health, and small business insurance. With over 30 years in the insurance sector, she specializes in simplifying complex insurance topics into actionable information. Amy collaborates with her team to translate insurance jargon into clear language for consumers, helping them understand insurance costs and find top-rated companies. Leveraging her extensive industry contacts, she develops Forbes Advisor's insurance content and analyzes state regulatory filings for insights. Amy's expertise has earned her features in major news outlets like The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal. She holds a Bachelor's degree in American Studies from Wesleyan University.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *